Judging Criteria

It is critically important that judging be based primarily on the scientific merit of the projects. This includes the project itself, the finalist’s knowledge of the scientific and/or engineering principles underlying it, and his/her comprehension of the project’s design, outcomes, and implications. A good project involves an original investigation or innovation and should not be merely a collection or demonstration of technology or scientific principles, however impressive. Some displays will be elaborate and professionally produced. This should be given credit only to the extent that it results in more effective communication of the work. A polished display is not a substitute for good science or engineering.

Preparing for Judging

• Read all the judging reference material provided, and become familiar with the Project Judging Form.
• Read the five-page reports of the projects you will be judging in the first round of judging, which will be available online. You will not have time to do this during the day of the Science Fair.
• Attend the judge’s orientation and dinner.
• Following the briefing session, review the project displays in the absence of the finalists.
• Read the Logbooks.
• Prepare preliminary interview questions.
• Evaluate the display.

Pre-Judging Activities